Tuesday, October 31, 2006

Sophism

Vitanza's article, unfortunately, didn't clear up any of the questions I have about rhetoric and the finer points of arguments. Or maybe it's just that I didn't read through it enough times, or even that sophist's principles aren't meant to be understood by those who do not follow the theory.

I really don't have much else to say that wouldn't be space-filling blathering, so I guess I won't count this as one of my top 10 blogs.

Wednesday, October 25, 2006

Rhetoric and Audience

I found Corbett’s article on classic rhetoric in the composition classroom to be the most influential for me, of the readings from this week…and no, this is not because it was the shortest of the three. I will be the first to admit that my knowledge of rhetoric is close to nil; my undergraduate studies of rhetoric left me with a sort of lofty definition: “the study of argument”. Now, I know there’s more to it than that, and I could extrapolate a little, but my ability to explain rhetorical studies is vague.

Still, I found Corbett’s explanation and defense of classical rhetoric terms and practices food for thought for my composition classes. I agreed with his statement that “students find theme-writing so unrealistic” because of the vague audience that they usually have to write to – the “general public”.

I also agree with and found that I have put into practice his idea that students need a solid, concise thesis statement before they can properly start an academic paper. I actually had them do an exercise in class yesterday (the day I handed out the assignment sheet for the research paper) that guided them through a self-questioning process in order to produce a thesis statement for their yet-unwritten papers.

I would be interested in what our creative writing focused people in this class have to say about his statement, near the end of the paper, of “But hasn’t the cult of self-expression had a fair chance to prove itself in the classroom? How often does the student with creative promise even show up in our classrooms?” He is basically saying, in my opinion, that classic rhetoric methodology should replace the majority of creative expression in academic writing. I don’t think they are mutually exclusive.

It seems like the theme for this week’s reading can be boiled down, yet again, to one word “audience”. In fact that seems to be one of the major themes for this class for the semester. All of which leads me to the question: How do we make a more concrete audience for our students to use for their Comp 110 papers? Or, how do we help them learn to seek their own audience? It seems that audience training is important to the English department here, but not to all of them. So, how do we teach them to help themselves in finding and/or creating an audience for future, non-110 papers?

Thursday, October 12, 2006

Drafting Differences

Starting with the last article first...I have some fairly strong agreements and disagreements with Flowers and Hayes' argument for a cognitive process of writing. I agree wholeheartedly that writing is, in part, an intellectual process. To think that writing "just happens", and that it doesn't run through multiple processes of the mind is absurd. My disagreements lie with, and this is totally a worldview/personality difference, the insistence for charts and discussion of hierarchies of goals and that ilk. I guess then, my issue lies more with the need to overthink what I see as a natural process. Granted, it obviously is a learned process, but I see the potential to write as a latent, natural process, that requires teaching only to give form to the process.

I really enjoyed the Harris article, and the resulting discussion for the matter, on one-and-multi draft writers. Honestly, before dealing with this article, I had always considered one-draft writers simply lazy or procrastinators. And while I still don't know that I myself will ever be a one-draft writer, I can understand where they are coming from now. It was also neat to see practical application of previous readings for class in this one. I had struggled some with the reader versus writer based prose, and this helped me to better understand how the focus of writing can be influenced by audience.

The information discussed in Sommer's article about revision...mostly wasn't new to me, but I do feel like I benefitted from gaining an understanding of the format of the types of articles that I may someday write and publish in scholarly journals.

Thursday, September 28, 2006

Elbow and the Internet

As is to be expected, I enjoyed the Elbow article more than the other two. They were not horrible, I just am an Elbow fan. I've said before that much of the Crosstalk book authors leave me feeling stupid when I read them, but Elbow is always more clear, even if I do not agree with everything he writes. I do not know if a writer can ever turn off the audience of self. I wholeheartedly believe that writers can tune everyone else out and just write for themselves, but even in a diary or journal, you are writing for the audience of the future self.

The Lunsford article on textual ownership was, once again, best understood after class discussion. It reminded me of an old friend and classmate who believed that information should never be copyrighted or classified...that it should be available for all. This is a very grey area in my opinion, because it is hard to own an idea, but that's what most information is...creative and/or informative shaping of ideas. I understand though, that this is a world where what you own is often the deciding factor of who you are, regardless of whether it is financial or intellectual capital (Dr.Burling's influence is starting to show), but I also think that information should not be hoarded. That is my head speaking, though, as my heart would want to receive full credit and ownership for any stories, poems, ideas, projects that I produced.

The narrative-based article on safe spaces for women to write should have appealed to my fairly strong feminist side, but in reality, it did not. I can understand where the woman felt like her personal space had been violated when the 'master male' student let himself into her web server, but even metaphorically, I feel that rape is a too-strong comparison. And speaking from a teaching point of view, the narrative styled formatting made it hard to pull pithy passages. There were ideas to be summarized, but not necessarily 'quotable quotes'. I agree with their concerns about creating a safe space to write, but I don't know if that need is really only for the women in our classes....it applies to every student.

Thursday, September 21, 2006

Are you really out there, audience?

I take a sort of joy in the fact that I am writing in my blog, where I know who my intended audience is, about the concepts of addressed versus invoked audience. It's all very post-modern and 'meta'.

I agree, to an extent, with Chris' confusion in class yesterday about the idea of a fictionalized audience. I think though, that I have more of a problem with Ong's belief that an audience is more real for an orator than it is for a writer. There is always a real, actual audience for any piece of writing, even if the audience is simply the writer-as-a-reader of their own work. It is, instead, a matter of 'determining' who the audience is, not a matter of creating a previously non-existing audience.

I also do not understand how a reader can take on a role that requires them to ficitionalize themselves. I understand the part about taking on a role; I have two reader roles -- with pen in hand and for pleasure.

Maybe I am too caught up in semantics here, but fiction to me means 'not real'. Therefore, the audience is never fictional or constructed because the reader all ready exists (regardless if the reader is the writer or someone else).

The Lunsford/Ede piece was interesting to read as a direct follow up to Ong's writing. I've never before read a (partial) critique of an author that I had just read. I enjoyed that this essay mostly dealt with the strengths and weaknesses of several theoretical models, instead of taking the usual very distinct bias that some of the other essays in the book take. I understand that the purpose of writing a paper on a specialized topic (or almost any writing at all) is to make an argument, but at the level that I am at in the world of composition theory, it is occasionally good to just become more informed on something.

Thursday, September 14, 2006

It's Friere Day, Yeah!

So, once again, I found twice as much benefit in discussion yesterday as I did reading the essays and chapters by myself. Friere is infinitely more relatable than some of the other topics we've covered, but I'm learning that I simply "get" more out of talking about something. I've always been a very verbal learner, but before taking this class, I could usually get a good grasp of the things I've read. I also kind of (read: arrogantly) felt that because my undergrad degree was in English EDUCATION that I would somehow magically understand all the pedagogical stuffs. Tis not the case, though I am learning, bit by bit.

Now my reactions to the readings themselves: I had heard, vaguely, of the banking method before this week, but had never really read much about it. After three years teaching high school, in a place that virtually required the banking method, my knee jerk reaction was to hate it on principle. It seemed, and still somewhat seems to me, common sense that students need dialogue and to be questioned and challenged. And it seems equally common sense to me that there needs to be mutual respect and a general love for humanity in order to create an environment (in the classroom or out) where good dialogue can be generated.

And while I do believe all of the above, I truly think that the banking method is not only useful, but necessary in almost every classroom. Depending on the class, the extent of which the banking method would be useful fluctuates. Even within the English and Composition classrooms, students need basic vocabulary and knowledge of formats. And while these could be taught in a 'discovery' or dialogue method, it would be a waste of time.

Sunday, September 10, 2006

Tardy Post for week of 9/5 - 9/8/06

First and foremost, I wanted to comment on the discussion about the readings before I talked about this week's readings, themselves. Class on Friday was, for me, one of the most beneficial classes I've had this year. Sometimes with the articles we are assigned, I get bogged down in the length and the big words, and I end up only understanding half (if that) of what is being explained in the article. But the group mini-presentations left me going "Oh!" a lot, in my head.

Now, as for the readings themselves, I "got" the most of the Royster article on cross-boundary discourse and the least from Bizzell's article on cognition. I feel that the monitoring and modeling how to blur the line of the "Other" is something very practical, and can be applied both to our classrooms and our everyday lives. I mean, being more consciously aware of what we say about people who are something we are not, be it race/gender/religion, seems common sense. And being that we are teachers, regardless of our political pedagogy, we have the need to model that way of thinking for our students. And it has to be modeled, because I don't believe that is something that can be taught.

The Kirsch/Ritchie article on politics of location seemed to be mostly about how to handle research subjects. I probably need to go back and read this one again; not because I didn't understand the concepts in it, but because the idea of human subjects as something that I might be working with is so new to me that my focus was on that. I guess part of my brain always thought that English majors only studied the literature and writings themselves, but I am seeing now that there is more to it than that.

This week's readings were clearer and more beneficial to me personally than some of the previous ones because I feel like I finished the week understanding (at least the main point) of each of them.